Comparison
Returning something without a receipt
Almost no store says a flat yes. What changes is whether you get your money back or store credit at a price they choose — and whether a card lookup can rescue you.
| Retailer | Without a receipt | You get | ID required | Card lookup |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Amazon | Accepted | original payment | No | Available |
| Costco | Accepted | original payment | Yes | Available |
| Kohl's | Accepted | lowest sale price credit | Yes | Available |
| Sam's Club | Accepted | original payment | No | Available |
| Nordstrom | Accepted | store credit | Yes | Available |
| Apple | Accepted | original payment | No | Available |
| Target | Limited | case by case | Yes | Not offered |
| Walmart | Limited | store credit | Yes | Available |
| Best Buy | Limited | original payment | Yes | Available |
| Home Depot | Limited | store credit | Yes | Available |
| Macy's | Limited | case by case | Yes | Available |
| Nordstrom Rack | Limited | store credit | Yes | Available |
| T.J. Maxx | Limited | lowest sale price credit | Yes | Not offered |
| Marshalls | Limited | lowest sale price credit | Yes | Not offered |
| Nike | Limited | store credit | Yes | Available |
| Sephora | Limited | case by case | Yes | Available |
| Ulta Beauty | Limited | store credit | Yes | Available |
| IKEA | Limited | lowest sale price credit | Yes | Available |
| Menards | Limited | lowest sale price credit | Yes | Available |
| Lowe's | Refused | no refund | Yes | Available |
"Store credit at the lowest price" is the rule that costs people the most money: the refund is valued at the item's lowest recent selling price, not what was paid. Where a card lookup exists, using it converts the return back into a full refund.