Comparison

Returning something without a receipt

Almost no store says a flat yes. What changes is whether you get your money back or store credit at a price they choose — and whether a card lookup can rescue you.

RetailerWithout a receiptYou getID requiredCard lookup
AmazonAcceptedoriginal paymentNoAvailable
CostcoAcceptedoriginal paymentYesAvailable
Kohl'sAcceptedlowest sale price creditYesAvailable
Sam's ClubAcceptedoriginal paymentNoAvailable
NordstromAcceptedstore creditYesAvailable
AppleAcceptedoriginal paymentNoAvailable
TargetLimitedcase by caseYesNot offered
WalmartLimitedstore creditYesAvailable
Best BuyLimitedoriginal paymentYesAvailable
Home DepotLimitedstore creditYesAvailable
Macy'sLimitedcase by caseYesAvailable
Nordstrom RackLimitedstore creditYesAvailable
T.J. MaxxLimitedlowest sale price creditYesNot offered
MarshallsLimitedlowest sale price creditYesNot offered
NikeLimitedstore creditYesAvailable
SephoraLimitedcase by caseYesAvailable
Ulta BeautyLimitedstore creditYesAvailable
IKEALimitedlowest sale price creditYesAvailable
MenardsLimitedlowest sale price creditYesAvailable
Lowe'sRefusedno refundYesAvailable

"Store credit at the lowest price" is the rule that costs people the most money: the refund is valued at the item's lowest recent selling price, not what was paid. Where a card lookup exists, using it converts the return back into a full refund.